Showing posts with label Ideology Analysis of The Debt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ideology Analysis of The Debt. Show all posts

Monday, February 20, 2012

Phillpott, The Debt



The movie The Debt can be seen as being both implicit and explicit in its ideology. There are moments where the story seems to be
told without a particular slant, but I believe the movie's true ideology is explicit. The audience is told the story of three agents through the use of flashbacks. The agents (Stephen, David, and Rachel) were supposed to kidnap Dieter Vogel and bring him back to Israel for a trial because of his atrocious actions against the Jews during WWII. They kidnap him, but are unable to leave at their assigned time. Eventually, Voge lescapes, but the agents all agree that they will tell the world that Rachel killed him. They figure that he will never show his face again so their story will be safe. Yet, David is not really happy with this decision because he wants Vogel to stand a fair trial and not to be thought of as dead. This is where the explicit ideology comes.



In the scene where David visits Rachel when they are older after her interview, he explains that he has been traveling for years just looking for Vogel. Rachel asks him why he has continued to search, but David tells her that he wants to bring Vogel in for justice and then tell a journalist the true story. Rachel tells him that she doesn't agree because she has to look out for her daughter. David is representing the movie's real ideology--you should always tell the truth even if it will hurt you. David's viewpoint is there to persuade the audience that it is morally right and the only true course of action for the characters to take.


The second scene of explicit ideology comes at the end when Rachel is at the hospital to kill Vogel. She writes a note to a journalist explaining what really happened over thirty years before on their mission. This scene is meant to show that the morally right thing to do has finally been done. The truth is going to be told to the world and justice will be carried out. Rachel has made a decision that will hurt her daughter and herself, but she knows it is still the right thing to do.

Saturday, February 18, 2012

Engineer, Ideology Analysis of The Debt


The Debt is a brilliant espionage thriller film directed by John Madden and released in 2010. The central character is Rachel Singer (Helen Mirren) and the supporting actors are Stephan Gold (Tom Wilkinson) and David Peretz (Ciaran Hinds). The film is about three Mossad agents sent to East Germany in 1965 to capture a Nazi war criminal Dr. Vogel (Jesper Christensen) and bring him back to trial in Israel. The opening scene shows the three agents returning home after successfully completing their mission. The middle part of the film shows conflict among the three agents in how they handle the doctor. The mission fails when Dr. Vogel escapes and they are forced into a pact by Stephan to admit that the mission was successful and that Dr. Vogel was shot by Rachael. The three agents live through this lie for thirty-three years until David commits suicide and they are forced to bring out the truth to the public.

The ideology if the film is implicit because the protagonists Rachel and David are in conflicting views against the antagonist Stephan who forces them to cover up about what really happened with Dr. Vogel. The true ideological problem that needs to be raised is why the viewers have not been asked to question the Israel government’s commitment to resolve war atrocities committed by Nazi war criminals. But instead, the viewers are asked to look closely at the three Mossad agents and the turmoil they go through for thirty-three years. The message being sent in this film is that the government does not want to be involved when there is a mess up or in failed missions. Instead the film shows how the blame is shifted squarely on patriotic people who are used as pawns and scapegoats to partake in government missions. In the end, it is unfortunate that the three innocent Mossad agents are left to resolve the conflict by cleaning up the mess of 1966, thirty-three years later by killing Dr. Vogel.